Thursday, January 21, 2010
Investment Sins Part 7 - Gluttony
Signs of an Investor Afflicted by Gluttony
The book illustrates four examples of investors who are afflicted by gluttony. Are you afflicted as well? The four signs are described below:-
1) Buying in the worst possible markets
Normally, the correct mindset for an investor to adopt is to buy in plunging markets and sell in markets which are soaring on hope and optimism. Investing gluttons, however, buy indiscriminately and without doing proper due diligence or research. So it’s akin to throwing darts on a dartboard to try to pick those few winners. These people also like to take a small piece of positive information to justify a BUY, even though it may just appear to glitter like gold on the surface and have no substance within.
2) Viewing their investing with false optimism
Gluttons are great deceivers, of themselves! They tend to perceive everything positively, and remember their winners best while conveniently forgetting their losers. These are the guys who tend to claim they make money whenever they are at a cocktail party; of course this is simply the result of selective amnesia.
3) Becoming a 24/7 investor
The gluttons become so obsessed with investing that it dominates all aspects of their lives, including their personal lives and private time. As a result, they often neglect their jobs, loved ones and get into trouble at work because they are overly focused with investments. There is no proper balance in their lives and this mental state is unhealthy in the medium-term.
4) Investing heavily in small caps and options
The author mentions here the glutton usually gravitates towards small caps because they are cheap in absolute terms and also because of their volatility and potential for profits. The problem is that most small caps are not able to generate consistent gains for their shareholders in terms of earnings growth, and most fall by the wayside and fizzle out. The glutton neglects his research and will choose to punt recklessly in the hopes of quick profits; and he does this to his detriment.
So the above are the four classic tell-tale signs of investing gluttony. The book goes on to mention why gluttons almost invariably lose money. Four factors are stated but only three are applicable in Singapore’s context as one of them mentions about capital gains taxes on short-term trading gains, versus taxes on long-term capital gains. These are stated below:-
a) Commissions
This is the classic sandpapering of your gains when you trade frequently, and magnification of your losses – all the hallmark of the fervent glutton who trades frenetically as if there were no tomorrow. Even if commissions were much lower through the use of online brokers, gluttons tend to trade so frequently that the costs eventually add up and erode their gains. Commissions are one of the most insidious aspects of high-frequency trading, and gluttons often fall prey to this without realizing it.
b) Bid-Ask Differential
This represents the difference between what a buyer is willing to buy a stock for, and what a seller is willing to sell for. For liquid stocks, the differential may not be very significant, but for other less liquid stocks there could be a significant bid-ask differential of a few bids. This also adds up to additional trading costs if one decides to enter and exit in a hurry.
c) Over-Reaction Bias
This is the effect of over-reacting to positive or negative news and jumping in and out of the market, thus unknowingly exacerbating the reaction bias associated with this behavioural finance trait. Gluttons usually believe they can get in early when they first hear about the news, and get out quickly before the bad news hits the fan. While it is true that some money can be made this way, it is hardly consistent as the market does not always react as anticipated to news, as some of it may already be reflected in the share price. Also, once the news is out, most of the movement may already be reflected in the opening price for the day, thus obliterating any chances of profiting from such news.
So how does one rid themselves of this investing addiction? The key is to go Cold Turkey, but do so gradually. Just like a smoker cannot be expected to quit in just one day, or his nicotine craving would be too great and his withdrawal symptoms would be unbearable; so should the investing glutton slowly wean himself off trading. Some of the suggested methods are:-
i) Reserve 5-10% of your portfolio for “play” or active trading
Well, as the saying goes, if you simply HAVE to get your daily trading fix, make sure you limit the amount of money you risk, and by limiting it to 5-10% of your portfolio you also restrict yourself from losing too much. Of course, mental fortitude is also needed to prevent oneself from raising this limit to say 20% and higher in order to get more funds to “play”.
ii) Refuse to invest in the stocks and funds that everyone is talking about
In other words, steadfastly refuse to follow the herd mentality! It’s easier said than done though, and once again you need to tell yourself to hold your horses and not do the popular thing. Once you start getting used to this, it’s the first step towards curing that gluttony addiction.
iii) Substitute buying “beaten-up” stocks for high performing ones
One should actually do some real research for once and purchase quality, and not quantity. In this case, “beaten-up” may be beaten up for a good reason, as fundamentals may deteriorate or the Company may be managed poorly. Cut the losers out and focus instead on companies with good management, clear earnings growth visibility, good cash flow generation and are selling at cheap valuations.
iv) Increase Benchmarking
It’s a good idea to benchmark against an index to see how you are doing objectively in terms of performance, so this is an effective way to stop deluding yourself that you are better than everyone else!
v) Reduce the number of trades gradually
As mentioned before, do the slow cold turkey instead of the instant one. This is because addictions are mental habits which are difficult to break off suddenly. Therefore, slowly reduce trading until it becomes no more than an afterthought, and after that you should do fine.
vi) Use a passive or index strategy when investing in small caps
Since the risk of small caps is much higher than blue chips, it is advisable to use a passive strategy of investing in an index fund of small caps to diversify away the risk of any single company collapsing. In this way, you mitigate the chances of losing a huge chunk of money and also slowly kill that inner demon of a glutton within.
I hope the above is helpful, and the last section of the Investing Sins series will tackle the issue of Sloth, or laziness. Watch out for it soon!
Wednesday, December 03, 2008
In this sixth installment of my investment sins series, let's explore the emotion of anger (sometimes also known as "wrath") and how it can screw up our investments. As the saying goes, don't get angry, get even ! There is some truth to this statement as it is basically trying to tell us to calm down and think through the situation in order to identify the optimal solution to be implemented. Anger is an emotion which clouds our judgement and causes us to do impulsive things which we may later regret.
Basically, the book by Maury Fertig talks firstly about the targets of wrath, which is where we, as investors, like to target our anger when something goes wrong. During bear markets (such as the current one) where everyone sees falling prices and gets a sense of helplessness about their investments tanking daily, anger can be a particularly powerful emotion. The problem is that investors generally do not know where to channel this anger constructively and end up blaming i) The Media (for dispensing an endless barrage of bad news which makes markets tank) ii) CEOs (for not managing their companies properly) iii) Financial Analysts (for downgrading their favourite stock) or iv) a Group with a Vested Interest (such as the Federal Reserve which is responsible for the mega bailout plan for auto-makers and financial institutions). Whatever the case, anger which is misplaced often has negative effects for the investor, as it causes him to lose focus and make bad investment decisions.
Next, Mr. Fertig talks about being "normally angry" and being "sinfully angry". Confused ? He goes on to explain the differences between these two terms.
Sinfully Angry
1) Never blames himself for an investment which has gone wrong
2) Always looks for scapegoats to vent his anger upon
3) Makes inpulsive investment decisions (in the heat of the moment)
4) Finds the stock market more stressful and aggravating than other aspects of his life
5) Is only able to relieve angry feelings by making another (impulsive) investment
6) Major investment decisions are often preceded by a bout of anger
7) Views investing as a macho competition where aggressive, instinctive behaviour is rewarded
Normally Angry
1) Upset with himself when he makes an investment loss
2) Avoids blaming others or making excuses when an investment does not work out
3) Allows anger to dissipate before making an investment decision
4) Becomes upset about news and investments, but no more than other aspects of his life which may also be upsetting
5) No correlation or pattern between anger and making an investment
6) Sees investing as a cerebral (thinking) activity which rewards analysis and objectivity and tries to avoid strong emotions such as anger to cloud the decision-making process
The last traits in both sinfully and normally angry should be of note. If one treats investing as a competition or a war, then aggression and anger would probably dominate your thought processes and not allow you to think clearly. By using objective analysis to guide your investment decisions, we can start off from a clear base of thinking and proceed to justify why we should be investing. Even if something goes wrong (and inevitably it does some time in our lives), at least the anger we feel is "normal" and not "sinful".
Although the chapter has other aspects of anger and discuss other important stuff, I will not attempt to "lift" too much from the book, but instead just highlight the more important sections. The final portion I would like to discuss is how we can keep anger out of our investing lives and stay cool. Here are a few suggestions/tips:-
A) Force yourself to take breaks from the investment world and your portfolio
It is good to "take a breather" sometimes and not be overly obsessed with one's investments or the stock market. When things go wrong, we minimize the probability of getting sinfully angry which may occur if we were too emotionally drawn into our investments.
B) Remind yourself that it's business, not personal
We must remember that investing should be done in a business-like manner, with careful thought and analysis. The stock market is not a living breathing person who is "out to get you". So one should avoid feeling as though we need to "take revenge" on the market for playing you out or to settle some personal grudge, because when we take things too personally, we tend to lose sight of the big picture - which is to get a decent return on our investment by owning good companies over the long-term (as a business owner).
C) Keep an Investment Journal
Make a record of all your investments, whether good or bad (a blog is also a good way to do this !). You can track investments you had made and whether they were a result of emotion or a careful thought process. One can also learn from mistakes and prevent anger from building up over "wrong" decisions if one has a good historical record of all decisions made (with supporting reasons of course).
D) Vent your anger productively
Yeah I know this sounds like what psychologists would say ! But the point to note is we can help the anger and frustration to dissipate if we channeled it properly, for example playing a game of football or squash (whack the ball hard !); or perhaps talking/confiding to a friend or loved one about how one feels.
To conclude, anger is a very destructive emotion - just look at how flaring tempers have destroyed families and caused crimes to be committed. The same goes for your investment performance, do NOT let anger destroy your investments - keep a cool head and always be logical and rational.
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
Avarice (another word for "greed"), our 4th discussed sin, strikes most investors during the peak of a bull market or during the middle of a raging bull market. It will be rather self-explanatory to the informed reader that greed is part of a normal investor's psychology, and therefore should be controlled as part of the fear/greed combination which occurs in such potent fashion while investing in the stock market.
However, what may not be obvious is that avarice can take different forms and may manifest itself in different ways (through various behaviours). The objective of this post is to highlight the various forms of avarice, how they are demonstrated and how to effectively curb such behaviour and prevent it from ruining our investing lives. First of all, Mr. Fertig's book points out that greedy investors tend to be unrealistic investors. To give an example, one may invest with the proper research framework and do their requisite reading and valuation tests to look for a suitable investment. However, when it comes to expectations of returns, avarice causes the investor to have wildly unrealistic expectations. He may envision a 200% rise in the stock price over a period of a year, or errorneously believe that his company is the best in the industry and immune to downturns. Such unrealistic expectations usually cause an investor to lose focus of reality and may cause recklessness and deep disappointment.
Another consequence of excessive greed is the desire to chase performance, which may result in even poorer performance than if one had just "stayed put". One example given in the book is the chasing of "hot" mutual funds (unit trusts) in the hope of maximizing returns. The greedy investor will "hop" from one year's top fund to next year's top fund, all the while switching from one to another in the (vain) hope of maximizing his wealth. However, this is usually a losing strategy as there is no guarantee that this year's top performing fund will continue to outperform. Frictional costs related to switching (some funds charge upfront sales charges) may also work to erode gains. leaving the investor worse off than if he had just invested in a low turnover, low expense ratio index fund !
A third result of greed is the failure to do proper due diligence. Greedy investors often throw caution to the wind and "invest" based on tips and rumours, with the hope of a windfall or jackpot (akin to lottery gambling). Such moves are often detrimental as investing based on such scanty and subjective information usually means the investor ends up not knowing what he is investing in, and this almost always spells trouble !
A further effect of greed is that it prevents investors from studiously monitoring their current investments for signs of any trouble. A greedy investor always assumes the best in his investments and fails to spot signs which may affect the companies which he invests in. This is a case of selective perception and the greedy investor wishes to look out for information which affirms his avarice, rather than objectively assessing information in order to make a more informed decision on whether to hold, or sell an under-performing investment.
The key to preventing greed from affecting our investment lives starts with proper self-control and being realistic. For example, it is unrealistic to expect to "beat" or even equal the performance of investing legends such as Peter Lynch, Warren Buffett and John Templeton. As retail investors, most of us are just average folk and therefore should accept a decent return on investment (in the region of 5-6% per annum is fair). Also, train yourself to assess an investment in an objective, calm and rational manner, so that greed does not cloud one's judgement and make an investment seem much better than it really is. And, probably the most difficult thing to do is to convince yourself that the market will eventually reward the patient, long-term investor and punish those who speculted without doing their due dilligence. In other words, greed does not pay and only in the long-term will this become obvious.
Warren Buffett's famous line is "You only know who's swimming naked when the tide goes out". Such a sentence is very true indeed in this current bear market, as most who purchased at very high valuations are sitting on significant paper losses now. Personally, I believe that greed will not give me a good outcome; thus I choose to "get rich slowly" instead of gunning for quick, ephemereal gains.
Friday, April 04, 2008
In the fourth installment of the investment sins series (which is taken from the book "The 7 Deadly Sins of Investing" by Maury Fertig), we take a look at Lust. The word lust is defined as "to have a yearning or desire, have a strong and excessive craving". The important words to take note of within the definition are "excessive" and "craving". Lust essentially stems from uncontrolled desire for something which overrides normal judgement and thinking. In relationships, lust has been known to result in cases of marital breakups as third-parties come into the picture. Lust usually has a negative connotation associated with it which implies a loss of control over one's faculties or objectivity; thus succumbing to their object of desire.
So after the English lesson, how does this all tie in with investing ? In investing, lust can manifest itself in various ways. Some examples of different types of lust are provided in Mr. Fertig's book, and I will detail each one briefly with an example:-
1) Holding on to a beloved investment much too long - This is a fairly common phenomenon for many investors and occurs when an investment that used to be a high performer starts to exhibit signs of deterioration. Remember that share prices are correlated to the earnings of a company; thus if a company can manage to grow or maintain earnings consistently into the future, there is no danger of gradual share price erosion. This case arises when one can only see good years ahead for his investment and fails to realize that the company has lost its competitive edge or perhaps its product is now "commoditized". As a result, margins begin to erode and profit begins to decline, leading to a drop in the value of the company. The lustful investor mistakenly believes that Mr. Market is mis-pricing the value of the company and continues to hold on even though it may be clear that fundamentals are decaying. Eventually, the share price will end up as a mere shadow of its former glory and the investor will be sitting on substantial paper losses; his dream and bubble pricked as if a child had pricked a balloon.
2) Becoming infatuated with an investment's surface looks and buying too soon - This is actually also a sign of sloth (not doing enough research) which I shall touch upon in a later part of this investment sins series. When one does not assess the risk/reward ratio of a potential investment and is attracted merely by the "sales talk", then it is also a sign of lust. Lusting after attractive products that is ! Most fund managers and those in the business of promoting alternative investments such as wine investing and land banking will come up with elaborate brochures (wuth large font sizes) as well as a mountain of positive data to support their claims of exceptional returns. It is all part of the sales tactics used by such individuals to generate more revenue and fees for their company. While I am NOT saying that all such investments are bad and that the salespeople are trying to con, one must be ever wary of tactics which may create an image of good returns while masking the true returns for an investment product. Sometimes, people may be lying by not telling the whole truth; or it may be a grey area. As an investor, we should NOT be too turned on by a product which appears to be appealing (and which seems to attract many "prominent" clients) and to compromise on your criteria for investing.
3) Developing an obsession with Plain Jane investments - This essentially means that one can lust after less "risky" investments in money-market funds which typically pay only about 1-2% return per annum; not even enough to cover out high inflation rate of 6.5%. Some people are obsessed with "safety" and refuse to place their money in unit trusts or equity markets for fear of losing everything; they thus become a lustful victim of the fallacy that fixed income securities are always "safer". On the contrary, being paid 1-2% by the bank or fund while inflation is 6.5% means that the real rate of return is a negative 4.5% (at best); thus your money is eroding away even as you feel secure that it is "safe". I have seen this happen with some of my friends and have been advising them to at least consider an index fund which gives market rates of return; instead of leaving their money in a fixed deposit (current rates are about 1.7% for 24 months and 1.9% for 36 months, and your money is locked in).
4) Lusting after gurus or certain fund managers - This is a particularly dangerous form of lust which involves the worship of one or more "gurus" who seem to know all about how markets move and what is best to invest in at any given point in time. There will always be talking heads on television and the news proclaiming that bear markets have arrived, we are in a recession or that commodities will enjoy a 10-year bull run. The lustful investor will latch on to one particular guru whom he/she adulates, and follow his/her recommendations blindly and without thinking. This can result in a lot of bad decisions beause failure to think about your investments usually gets one into big trouble. Thus, do NOT lust after a particular celebtiry (no matter how influential he may be). Instead, use your own logic and objective thinking and avoid those lustful thoughts !
In the next segment on investment sins, I will be touching on Avarice or Greed; one of the most pervasive investment sins ever !
Sunday, February 24, 2008
As the saying goes: "Pride goes before a fall", and this means that one who is proud will eventually fall because of his over-inflated ego. This investment sin is a very intruiging one as it discusses one's ego and shows how it affects one's investment decisions and philsophy. Vanity is a direct result of pride and being vain in investing simply means that you start worshipping yourself as if you could do no wrong.
Surprisingly (or maybe unsurprisingly), a survey conducted shows that men have a higher tendency to show excessive pride and an inflated ego when dealing with investments, and this could stem from the proverbial "male ego" which makes men aggressive and "kiasu". The "must0win" mentality may translate into fierce (and misplaced) pride in one's investing acumen and lead to one's eventual downfall. Women may also be prone to this but the survey mentioned that it is to a lesser extent. I am not going to go into a debate of the sexes but just wish to highlight that there are subtle differences in the way that men and women invest which are central to the topic I am discussing in this post. Perhaps I will discuss the differences between male and female investors in a future, more detailed post once I have collected sufficient "evidence" to form a theory.
Basically, to elaborate on the sin of pride, we look towards investors who "have to be right", no matter what ! This is a sure sign of pride at work but it is hard to be objective about oneself, so most will not be able to see that they are blinded by their own narcissistic tendencies. Some investors may have hit it big once or twice with certain investments, and suddenly they feel they are experts in a particular industry or subject matter. There are also others who may feel over-confident in their "system" used to beat the market repeatedly and let down their guard, only to be proven wrong in a big way thus incurring significant losses.
The danger of this sin is that it is rather insidious and creeps up on one slowly. As one's wealth grows as a result of successful investing, one may get more and more proud of his accomplishments and feel "invulnerable". This is a danger signal and is the start of a downward spiral into vanity and excessive pride in one's abilities. There is a term for this kind of misplaced pride: HUBRIS. Hubris can blind an investor and cause him to behave irrationally.
Below are some examples which are highlighted in Mr. Maury Fertig's book regarding investing behaviours that are signs of hubris:-
1) Refusing to sell an investment because you cannot admit you made a mistake - This is a classic case of refusing to acknowledge mistakes, and is a value investing no-no as well.
2) Throwing good money after bad - This is an extension of point 1 above and as the investor feels he could NOT have made a mistake, decides to average down to prove his point. Unfortunately, it may be the case of throwing money down the drain as the company's fundamentals may be deteriorating. Thus, one has to objectively evaluate a company to see if the fall in price is a result of worsening fundamentals, or simply sentiment-driven.
3) Possessing an unbalanced portfolio - This actually means that you are over-concentrating your investments in one narrow area (e.g. retail companies or just oil and gas companies) which may not be a bad move assuming you know the inside out of the industry and the nitty-gritty details. But if one is suffering from hubris, he may THINK he knows a lot when he actually does not, and thus fails to properly diversify his investments. Only if one truly understands one's investments should one concentrate them, as even Warren Buffett mentions that diversification is a protection against ignorance.
4) Making esoteric investments or following an arcane strategy - Overly proud investors usually like to be the first (pioneer) to discover a new type of investment or to dip their foot in the latest hot fads to show that they are "up-to-date". This behaviour may backfire badly if insufficient research has been done or if he is just trying to be different from the crowd for the sake of it. Remember that investing is not about showing off one's style but to achieve personal goals of wealth and financial freedom.
Thus, the above illustrates what could happen if one was "infected" with hubris. I am sure that all of us, at some point in time, have been guilty of the above sin in one form or another. The important thing is to recognize the sin and take active steps to prevent it from recurring, and to correct the mistake if already made. Make a conscious effort to examine yourself and your investments objectively instead of letting ego and pride go to your head. In this way, we can be assured of investment success in the long run.
Sunday, December 02, 2007
To continue the series from the introduction where I had left off, I will be introducing the first "sin" of investing and elaborating more on it, as well as giving my personal views. Envy is something which is familiar to most people, especially Singaporeans. In a rat-race society where the most kiasu (i.e. scared to die) fight for survival, comparisons are inevitable. Just look at the throngs of parents fluffing their peacock feathers while boasting about their sons' or daughters' achievements; it's enough to make one cringe. Many children have the competitive spirit ingrained in them from young, and along with it comes envy; as not everyone is blessed enough to have either good looks, money or big brains. Thus, envy should be a part of everyday life unless one is either very blur, very ignorant or simply lives in his own world (hermit).
So how does the concept of envy find its way into investing and behavioural finance ? Envy occurs when an investor looks to another's portfolio or investment decisions, and always feels that the other person is better. This envy causes resentment to build up, as well as jealousy and probably even impotent rage as to why the other investor consistently does better. The envious investor does not bother to look inward and within himself to examine his own flaws and inadequacies; instead he attributes most of his failures to his object of envy, and starts to build resentment towards the person. Being envious can severely cloud your objective thinking and judgement as it will make one so smitten with "beating" the other person that you can lose track of rationality.
To give an example, suppose Larry (all names are fictional) always sees John as a friend and they engage in friendly rivalry, whether on the soccer field or in school. Larry has always been the better one at sports as well as grades and feels proud that he does better than John in most things. However, when they grow up and go into the adult world, John's investing acumen and patience sees him scoring multi-baggers and earning him lots of money; while Larry has made significant losses by trading without basis and succumbing to bouts of emotional distress. Increasingly, Larry feels that he is "losing out" to John even though he is thinks he is supposedly smarter than John, and as a result he feels more and more resentful. Eventually, he begins mimicking John's each and every move, buying when he buys and selling when he sells. As a result, he ends up losing even more money due to his indiscriminate behaviour. Envy has caused him to follow John's investment decisions blindly and he fails to understand that each individual should have his own unique method of investing.
For myself, when I first started out, I was also wondering why others seem to be making money while I was either making less, or losing money. There was a tinge of envy present as I was always wondering what the rest had that I did not. Fortunately for me, I managed to analyze my mistakes and realize that I should not go down the path of envy as it is self-destructive and serves no good purpose. Nowadays, if I hear someone doing better than me or having a higher % gain, I just shrug it off as I am satisfied with my own investment philosophy and pleased with my own personal progress. Letting envy take control would unravel my carefully prepared plans for building wealth slowly but steadily, and I did not wish to let that happen.
Wednesday, November 07, 2007
Investment Sins Part 1 – Introduction and Overview
This is a new series which I am introducing as part of a discussion on behavioural finance, and it is also predicated upon the writings and intelligent insights gained from a book written by Maury Fertig called “The 7 Deadly Sins of Investing”. In subsequent posts, I will write more about the new area of behavioural finance, as this is a new field which has only recently become very popular with academics and there is now a body of research under-way to find out more about the emotional aspects of investing and personal financial decision-making.
This overview will introduce the 7 sins specifically talked about in the book, and each subsequent post will discuss and elaborate on one of the sins. I will not be delving into any of the examples featured in the book (as that would be a violation of copyright, so go read the book yourself hehe); my aim is to focus on the sin itself and discuss my own personal experience with that emotion, and how it has affected my investment decision-making. Consequently, I will give suggestions on how to combat and avoid the sin and ways to learn from our past behaviour so that the sin is not repeated again in future.
The sins are as follows (in no particular order of how nasty they are!):-
1) Envy – One of the more pervasive sins around, this causes a person to envy another’s success or portfolio and in turn creates a lot of negative emotions.
2) Vanity/Pride – The failure to admit a mistake can distort objective thoughts and cause one’s ultimate ruin as a company spirals into the red.
3) Lust – Lusting for more riches is an effect of greed and when one chases markets to higher highs, one is playing the Greater Fool game.
4) Avarice – Knowing that not everyone can do well all the time and that mistakes are inevitable.
5) Anger/Wrath – A pretty common investing sin in forums when I see people railing about the losses they made and blaming the market instead of themselves. The desire to “take revenge” always clouds judgement and causes further mistakes to be made.
6) Gluttony – Do not let the market consume you, as it will cause burnout very quickly !
7) Sloth – The ultimate sin of being lazy and just letting your portfolio rot towards the core.
I will expand on each of these sins in future posts and how they have affected me, and in turn welcome comments on how we can all avoid such sins in our investing life.
